We are all inevitably prisoners of our history and experience…
Entries from 2013
…un patrimoine millélaire exceptionnel…
once upon a wine – nicely done!
a little something from the weekend…

It was nice to have the counterpoint of one last glass from the Gérard Mugneret, before diving into the 2004 Pascal Lachaux, Clos St.Denis – this CSD, from the start had borderline P to my taste – sometimes it’s there, sometimes not. This particular bottle was a little reduced and this reduction never blew off – it was on a modest level, but enough to mask any pyrazines. Interestingly for me was the clear extra width and depth and interest that this wine had over the 2010 villages Vosne despite coming from the weakest vintage in a long, long time – it really underlines that it’s hard to go wrong if you buy from good makers!
The 2002 Louis Jadot, Vosne-Romanée 1er Les Petits Monts – was its usual sinewy, but silky self. It doesn’t quite have the padding of its youth but it is a wine that has always remained open and ‘giving’. Jacques Lardière once told me that he thought P-M ‘hardly a 1er Cru, or at least a very modest one’ – lucky then that this wine used to be had for a modest price 😉 Still, far from modest drinking – yum!
guy amiot’s 2011 chassagne vv…

2011 Guy Amiot, Chassagne-Montrachet Vieilles-Vignes
I can’t put my finger on why, but I’ve always loved this label – sometimes the wine is less interesting – but not today, just! The nose is wide and high-toned yet also understated and quite pretty. Slightly anonymous entry, but the flavour builds through the mid-palate. In the end, this is very nice, still showing a hint of oak in the finish for now.
Rebuy – Yes
(tawdry?) – is that strictly necessary…?
#HospicesdeBeaune Asia trip contd. Forbidden City tasting with A Jacquet (r), R Masse (centre) pic.twitter.com/DkfzKSboXh
— Anthony Hanson (@ahansonmw) November 10, 2013
With all the reduced yields in Burgundy, I find it more than a hint tawdry that the Christies marketing machine is pushing ever-harder in China to sell the latest Hospices de Beaune auction wines – particularly given that there is so little 2013 wine to sell. Clearly it is an unnecessary expense whilst times are hard for the many Côte de Beaune producers with little or no wine to sell…
That said, one assumes that Roland Masse is travelling on Christies’ coin, because this is Christies marketing their latest wine auction, and more particularly their own name (in this ‘potentially golden’ territory), it has nothing to do with the Hospices, whose 2013 wines could easily be sold in France alone – it has everything to do, however, with corporations trying to heat-up a market so that we all eventually pay more for a bottle of Beaune. Until that market moves on of-course. But who then, picks up the pieces? Willingly or otherwise, the Hospices are simply being used for Christies’ marketing.
Tawdry…
alain michelot’s 2007 les saint georges…
news on the bourgogne du jura purchase
From Decanter here…
gérard mugneret’s 2010 vosne-romanée…

2010 Gérard Mugneret, Vosne-Romanée
Plenty of colour here, roughly medium-plus. The nose begins with discretion; faint spice over a deeper note. With aeration the nose rounds out and adds a slight musk – it is very pleasant indeed. Right from the first sip there’s plenty of acidity, but like the nose, the flavours need time to round out as the structure supporting them, starts just a little brusque. Slowly but surely the wine comes together in the glass: The flavour is sweet, dark-red fruit, and whilst you never lose a little grainy texture in the mid-palate, there is excellent concentration and great length of flavour – the last seconds being more mineral. This may not be most suave-suited Vosne in the cosmos, but it has a great personality and quite some gravitas – and, of-course, it will only get better – lovely!
Rebuy – Yes

