FEED | SEARCH://
               Why Big Red Diary?

top wines from 1999 – #5 and last

Wine #5
The other corked bottle in this group, so onto bottle number 2.

Medium-plus cherry-red colour. The nose is very wide and somehow silky. It’s very slow to evolve, but first you note dried cranberry fruit before a subtle blackcurrant confiture, the last drops in the glass are sweet and red. Like the nose, my first impression of the palate is its silken texture, the second is the length – impossibly long – no other of these wines comes close and it’s not about bitter oak, it’s about a subtle sweetness that clings to the palate. There’s a real, but measured intensity about the palate, driven by perfect acidity and tannins that are there only if you search for them.

Despite the concentration there is perfect balance, this wine is the ultimate in sophistication. Monumental, it’s the best wine I’ve drunk this year…

7 responses to “top wines from 1999 – #5 and last”

  1. Tom Blach

    Here’s my guess, probably way off:
    1 Mugnier
    2 Jadot
    3 Ponsot
    4 Arnoux
    5 Drouhin

  2. Tom Blach

    Actually, reverse 2 and 3!

  3. Dan Perrelli

    What fun. Spin the bottle, played in a dark basement. In reverse order because I’m still confused by at least 1 and 2:

    5- Mugnier
    4- Arnoux
    3- Chezeaux
    2- Jadot
    1- Drouhin

    Will I be kissing a donkey when the lights turn on?

  4. Finesse

    My guess is:

    1 Chezeaux Clos St Denis
    2 Drouhin Les Petits Monts
    3 Arnoux Les Suchots
    4 Jadot Clos de Beze
    5 Mugnier Les Amoureuses

  5. Reto

    Hello Bill,
    great game again!

    My guess:

    1 Mugnier
    2 Drouhin
    3 Chezeaux
    4 Arnoux
    5 Jadot

    Cheers,
    Reto

Agree? Disagree? Anything you'd like to add?