only 56 years age difference…

Update 26.9.2017(27.9.2017)billn

I suppose that given the title, you might be forgiven for assuming that sub-title could be ‘A Las Vegas Wedding!’

Boringly, this is actually about wine, but certainly not about boring wines…

1959 Maison Roger Moreau, Gevrey-Chambertin “Clos Saint Jacques”
I bought a few of these at an auction in Switzerland – maybe 10 years-or-so ago. What can we make of the label? There’s no mention of 1er crus, and only ‘Gevrey-Chambertin Appellation Contrôlée’ though on separate lines. So it could easily be a villages Gevrey with a (not allowed) cuvée/brand name of CSJ – or it could actually be a Clos Saint Jacques – I will never know…
The nose starts with a note that makes me think ‘corked’ but it gets cleaner and cleaner, despite a little bloody iron and balsamic. With air the nose also offers flashes of beautiful florals – not enough for my taste – but sometimes – you never know what you’re going to get. The palate has weight, concentration and plenty of sweetness. It’s tasty enough, if never quite as nice as the (more and more) excellent nose – yet it’s a wine that’s very easy to take another glass – and I do! First question: Is it a real 1959? The weight and bulky sweetness, plus the lack of overt acidity are consistent with other wines from that vintage. Is it Clos Saint Jacques – well that’s anybody’s guess, but it’s holding up in excellent fashion – certainly more than you would expect from a villages wine – real or adulterated!

2015 Louis Jadot, Bourgogne Chardonnay
On 33% discount in my local co-op, so a logical choice at only 10.95 Swiss francs! DIAM sealed.
The first whiffs of aroma are classically, clichéd white burgundy; a toasty depth with a little side-plate of melted butter – time adding some weighty, ripe fruit – papya-style. Cold from the fridge this is both delicious and textured like silk. Some weight of modestly fat flavour but with fine balance – but only so long as keep it cool – not so much of a worry now we’re heading into the Autumn. Delicious wine for the price – really – bravo!
Rebuy – Yes

Agree? Disagree? Anything you'd like to add?

There is one response to “only 56 years age difference…”

  1. Mike Beltran27th September 2017 at 7:23 amPermalinkReply

    Someone got carried away with their type writer. You would think if it were CSJ that it would deserve its own label. Had an old Bordeaux with a type written 1945 and I am sure it was a fake. Chateau label but you can get those blank from an importer.

    • billn27th September 2017 at 7:34 amPermalinkReply

      Probably Mike, but it was a very different wine world in those days. Also a lot of wine was being ‘augmented’ with Algerian et-cetera in this era – that said, more for the export market (US/UK particularly) than the French market – though this was bought in Switzerland so who knows(?) I take this as curiosity; it’s 1959 Burgundian in style – everything else is conjecture…

Burgundy Report

Translate »

You are using an outdated browser. Please update your browser to view this website correctly:;