Because 140 characters will never be enough

Register or log in - lost password?  

Username
Password

Remember me

1. 

   Rick Dalia
   Member

   Jasper's book notes Arnoux's largest block in Echezeaux is in Ech-du-Dessus climat.
   Meadows' book does not include this as part of the domaine's holdings.
   What gives?

   Posted 6 years ago #
2. 

   bill nanson
   admin

   Somewhere, hidden and hopefully not lost, I have a small brochure from the domaine from about 2003 which showed the plots. It's possibly a vain search, but I'll see if I can find it for you Rick - no promises (or timescale!) mind...

   Posted 6 years ago #
3. 

   JT
   Member

   I believe the inconsistencies arise from the different interpretations between the border of Les Rouges du Bas and Echezeaux du Dessus. Clive's version shows a road separating the 2. Jasper's version shows a barely noticeable encroachment (quite similar to Clive's) whereas Allen's version show a decent size of Dessus encroaching into Rouges.

   Based on a brochure from the Domaine obtained last year, their holdings seem clearly within Rouges if we follow Clive and Jasper whereas there's some Dessus if we use Allen's.

   Complicated? Well, this is Burgundy.

   Posted 6 years ago #
4. 

   bill nanson
   admin

   JT said:
   Based on a brochure from the Domaine obtained last year, their holdings seem clearly within Rouges if we follow Clive and Jasper whereas there's some Dessus if we use Allen's.

   I guess JT answered that for me!

   Posted 6 years ago #
5. 

   Rick Dalia
   Member

   Thanks Bill and JT. Here in the U.S, sports commentators always make the assertion that "it's a game of inches." I suppose Burgundy is no exception!

   Posted 6 years ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.